The amphiphiles 1-octadecanol (octadecyl (stearyl) alcohol, ODA) and 1,2-dioleoylglycerol (DOG) were studied by IR spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction combined with multiscale theoretical modeling. The computations allowed us to rationalize the experimental findings and deduce the supramolecular structure of the formed assemblies while providing a fairly detailed insight into their hydrogen-bonding patterns. IR spectra revealed that the amphiphilic assemblies dramatically differ in structural order and hydrogen-bond strength, both being high in ODA and low in DOG. On the other hand, both compounds demonstrated common features, namely a splitting of the IR bands arising from O–H stretching vibrations (νOH) as well as complete hydrophobicity. However, the observed phenomena have different origins in the two amphiphiles. While the νOH split in ODA occurs due to a vibrational coupling along the string of inter-layer O–H⋯O hydrogen bonds, in DOG it arises from different types of hydrogen bonds (intra- and intermolecular). The hydrophobicity of ODA stems from the very tight O–H⋯O hydrogen bonding network connecting the opposite monolayers in a densely packed tilted crystalline phase (L_c′), whereas in DOG it occurs because the polar sites are locked inside reverted micellar-like assemblies. ODA and DOG illustrate that, in the assemblies of amphiphilic hydroxyl compounds, hydrogen bonds can be formed in a wide structural latitude, which is primarily governed by the chemical nature of apolar chains. Such a wide structural variability of OH-involving hydrogen bonds can be essential for the biological functioning of relevant molecules, such as glycolipids, acylglycerols, and, potentially, glycoproteins and carbohydrates.