Abstract
A small, inconspicuous scoria cone in western Bohemia, known as Komorní hůrka Hill, played a crucial role during the controversy between Plutonists and Neptunists over the origin of rocks in the first half of the nineteenth century. The year 2017 represents the 180th anniversary of one successful resolution of this debate: at the instigation of J.W. Goethe, adits were dug into this volcano to access its feeding system in order to observe whether volcanoes were fed by burning coal seams, or feeder dikes of magma. The adits into Komorní hůrka Hill were the first large earth-works with a solely scientific goal and with no commercial mining purposes. The basaltic feeder exposed in the adits decided definitively in favour of the Plutonists after decades of ongoing arguments with the Neptunists. Here, we summarize the overall history of this small volcano. A recently conducted ground geophysical survey confirmed the position of historical adits, marked on several archive sketches. The geophysical data, comprising ground magnetometry, electric resistivity tomography and refraction seismic profiles, also revealed the internal structure of the volcano, including the position of the feeder dike and the geometry of a lava flow emitted from the crater. With the position of these historical adits confirmed by geophysical survey, excavations can safely reopen these historical earth-works and provide access to a wider public. Komorní hůrka could then serve as an educational geosite to exhibit the structure of a small monogenetic volcano, as well as illustrating a stage in the history of Earth Sciences.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agricola G (1558) Bermannus, siue De re metallica dialogus, lib. I.; De ueteribus & nouis metallis, lib. II; De natura eorum quæ effluunt ex terra, lib. IIII; De ortu & causis subterraneorum, lib. V; De natura fossilium, lib. X.–Officina Frobeniana. Basileae. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.134630
Albrecht H (2016) Die Bergakademie Freiberg. Eine Hochschulgeschichte im Spiegel ihrer Jubiläen 1765 bis 2015. - Mitteldeutscher Verlag, 1–336, ISBN-13: 9783954625468
Bankwitz P, Schneider G, Kämpf H, Bankwitz E (2003) Structural characteristics of epicentral areas in Central Europe: study case Cheb Basin (Czech Republic). J Geodyn 35:5–32
Barrow G (1912) On the geology of Lower Dee-side and the southern Highland Border. Proc Geol Assoc 23:1–290
Berzelius JJ (1823) Untersuchungen des Mineralwassers von Karlsbad, Teplitz ind Königswart in Böhmen. Gilbert’s Annalen Physik 74:1–194 Leipzig
Blaikie TN, Ailleres L, Betts PG, Cas RAF (2014) Interpreting subsurface volcanic structures using geologically constrained 3-D gravity inversions: examples of maar-diatremes, Newer Volcanics Province, southeastern Australia. J Geophys Res: Solid Earth 119(4):3857–3878. https://doi.org/10.1002/2013JB010751
Boivin P, Besson JC, Briot D, Camus G, De Goër de Hervé A, Gourgaud A, Labazuy P, Langlois E, de Larouzière FD, Livet M, Mergoil J, Miallier D, Morel JM, Vernet G, Vincent PM (2009) Volcanologie de la Chaîne des Puys Massif Central Français. – 5th Edition, scale 1:25 000, 1 sheet
Bowden AJ, Burek CV, Wilding R (eds) (2005) History of palaeobotany: selected essays. – Geological Society, London, Special Publications 241, 304 pp.
Brenguier F, Coutant O, Baudon H, Dore F, Dietrich M (2006) High resolution seismic tomography of a Strombolian volcanic cone. Geophys Res Lett 33:L16314. https://doi.org/10.1029/2006GL026902
Brocx M, Semeniuk V (2007) Geoheritage and conservation: history, definition, scope and scale. J R Soc West Aust 90:53–87
Cas RAF, Wright JV (1987) Volcanic successions, modern and ancient: a geological approach to processes, products and successions. – Allen and Unwin, Winchester, Massachusetts, 528 pp.
Chlupáč I, Vacek F (2002) Thirty years of the first international stratotype: the Silurian-Devonian boundary at Klonk and its present status. Episodes 26:10–15
Desmarest N (1774) Mémoire sur l’origine et la nature du basalte à grandes colonnes polygones, déterminées par l’histoire naturelle de cette pierre, observée en Auvergne. – Histoire et mémoires de l’Académie Royale des Sciences, Année 1771, Paris, pp 705–775
Fischer T, Horálek J, Hrubcová P, Vavryčuk V, Bräuer K, Kämpf H (2014) Intra-continental earthquake swarms in west-bohemia and Vogtland: a review. Tectonophysics 611:1–27
Friese N, Bense FA, Tanner DC, Gustafsson LE, Siegesmund S (2013) From feeder dykes to scoria cones: the tectonically controlled plumbing system of the Rauoholar volcanic chain, Northern Volcanic Zone, Iceland. Bull Volcanol 75:717
Frisch SG (1825) Lebensbeschreibung A. G. Werners - nebst zwei Abhandlungen über Werners Verdienste um Oryktognosie und Geognosie Brockhaus Verlag, Leipzig
Fuertes-Gutierrez I, Fernandez-Martinez E (2012) Mapping geosites for geoheritage management: a methodological proposal for the regional park of Picos de Europa (Leon, Spain). Environ Manag 50:789–806
Geissler WH, Kämpf H, Kind R, Bräuer K, Klinge K, Plenefisch T, Horálek J, Zedník J, Nehybka V (2005) Seismic structure and location of a CO2 source in the upper mantle of the western Eger (Ohře) Rift, central Europe. - Tectonics, 24: https://doi.org/10.1029/2004TC001672
Geshi N, Oikawa T (2014) The spectrum of basaltic feeder systems from effusive lava eruption to explosive eruption at Miyakejima volcano, Japan. Bull Volcanol 76:797
Goethe JW (1786–1788) Italienische Reise.
Goethe JW (1790) Versuch die Metamorphose der Pflanzen zu erklären. Ettingersche Buchhandlung, Gotha, pp 1–79
Goethe JW (1809) Der Kammerbühl bei Eger ein Vulcan. Taschenbuch für die gesammte Mineralogie 3-4(1-24):365–369 Frankfurt am Main (Johann Christian Hermann)
Goethe JW (1810a) Zur Farbenlehre (theory of colours) Bd. II. Cotta, Tübingen 1810, 1–702
Goethe JW (1810b) Zur Farbenlehre (theory of colours) Bd. II. Cotta, Tübingen 1810, 1–786
Goethe JW (1822) Der Kammerbühl. - In Cotta E (ed.) Goethe’s Werken 30: 223–225
Goldfuss GA, Bischof GC (1817) Physikalisch-statistische Beschreibung des Fichtelgebirges 2: 133–135 Nürnberg.
Gottsmann J (1999) Tephra characteristics and eruption mechanism of the Komorní Hůrka Hill scoria cone, Cheb Basin, Czech Republic. Geolines 9:35–40
Gottsmann J, Tobschall H (1997) Petrographic and geochemical studies on the Komorni Hurka scoria cone, Cheb basin, Czech Republic. J Czech Geol Soc (J Geosci) 42:54
Gravis I, Németh K, Procter JN (2017) The role of cultural and indigenous values in geosite evaluations on a quaternary monogenetic volcanic landscape at Ihumātao, Auckland volcanic field New Zealand. Geoheritage 9:373–393
Guettard J-E (1752) Sur quelques montagnes de France qui ont été des volcans Mémoire de l'Académie Royale des Sciences de la France
Guntau M (2009) The rise of geology as a science in Germany around 1800. Geol Soc Lond, Spec Publ 317:163–177
Günther T, Rücker C, Spitzer K (2006) Three-dimensional modelling and inversion of dc resistivity data incorporating topography – II. Inversion. Geophys J Int 166:506–517
Haase KM, Renno AD (2008) Variation of magma generation and mantle sources during continental rifting observed in Cenozoic lavas from the Eger Rift. Central Europe Chem Geol 257:192–202
Harangi S, Molnár M, Vinkler AP, Kiss B, Jull AJT, Leonard AG (2010) Radiocarbon dating of the last volcanic eruptions of Ciomadul volcano, Southeast Carpathians, eastern-central Europe. Radiocarbon 52:1498–1507
Harangi S, Lukács R, Schmitt AK, Dunkl I, Molnár K, Kiss B, Seghedi I, Novothny Á, Molnár M (2015) Constraints on the timing of Quaternary volcanism and duration of magma residence at Ciomadul volcano, east–central Europe, from combined U–Th/He and U–Th zircon geochronology. J Volcanol Geothermal Res 301:66–80
Hartvich F, Valenta J (2011) The identification of faults using morphostructural and geophysical methods: a case study from Strašín cave site. Acta Geodyn. Geomater 8:425–441
Henriques MH, dos Reis RP, Brilha J, Mota T (2011) Geoconservation as an emerging geoscience. Geoheritage 3:1–12
Hetier JM, Guillet B, Brousse R, Delibrias G, Maury RC (1983) 14-C dating of buried soils in the volcanic Chaine des Puys (France). Bull Volcanol 46:193–202
Hibsch JE (1924a) Erläutungen zur geologischen Karte der Umgebung von Bilin. – Knihovna Státního geologického ústavu Československé republiky 8, Praha
Hibsch JE (1924b) Erläutungen zur geologischen Karte der Umgebung von Brüx. – Knihovna Státního geologického ústavu Československé republiky 11, Praha.
Hradecký P (1994) Volcanology of Železná and Komorní hůrka in Western Bohemia. Věst. Čes. Geol. Úst 69:89–92
Hutton J. (1795) Theory of the earth with proofs and Illustrations. – Edinburgh: printed for messrs Cadell, junior, and Davies, and William Creech, 1795-1899. ETH-Bibliothek Zürich, Rar 3971, https://doi.org/10.3931/e-rara-19688/PublicDomainMark
Jentzsch G, Korn M, Špičák A (2003) The swarm earthquakes in the area Vogtland/NW-Bohemia: interaction of tectonic stress and fluid migration in a magmatic environment. J Geodynamics 35:1–3
Kazancı N (2012) Geological background and three vulnerable geosites of the Kızılcahamam–Çamlıdere geopark project in Ankara, Turkey. Geoheritage 4:249–261
Knett J (1903) Mitteilungen der Erdbeben-Commision der Kiserlichen Akademie der Wisenschaften in Vien. Hof -und Staatsdruckerei, Wien
Kobell F (1853) Tafeln Bestimmt. – Alzad München, 46 pp.
Král R, Králová M (1961) Petrochemistry of the West Bohemian basalts V. Komorní hůrka near Františkovy Lázně. - Sbor. Vys. šk. chem. technol. v Praze, Fortschr Mineral, 5: 163–172.
Kvaček J, Kvaček Z (1992) Sternberg’s work Flora der Vorwelt, its significance and the state of the original collection. - Časopis Národního muzea v Praze. Řada přírodovědná 158:31–42
Loke MH, Barker RD (1996) Rapid least-squares inversion of apparent resistivity pseudosections using a quasi-Newton method. Geophys Prospect 44:131–152
Lustrino M, Wilson M (2007) The circum-Mediterranean anorogenic Cenozoic igneous province. Earth-Sci. Rev 81:1–65
Lutz H, Lorenz V (2013) Early volcanological research in the Vulkaneifel, Germany, the classic region of maar-diatreme volcanoes: the years 1774–1865. Bull Volcanol 75:743
Lyell J (1830) Principles of geology, vol 1, 1st edn. John Murray, London
Martínez-Pagán P, Gómez-Ortiz D, Martín-Crespo T, Manteca JJ, Rosique M (2013) The electrical resistivity tomography method in the detection of shallow mining cavities. A case study on the Victoria Cave, Cartagena (SE Spain). Eng Geol 156:1–10
Martinsson A (ed) (1977) The Silurian-Devonian boundary. Final report of the Committee on the Silurian-Devonian Boundary within IUGS Commission on Stratigraphy and a state of the art report for Project Ecostratigraphy, International Union of Geological Sciences, series A, number, vol 5. Schweizerbartsche Verlag, Stuttgart, 349 pp
Mertes H, Schmincke H-U (1983) Age distribution of volcanoes in the West-Eifel. Neues Jahrb Geol Palaont Monatsh 166:260–293
Molina JI (1810) Saggio sulla historia civile del Chili. – Seconda Edizione, Bologna, 302 pp.
Moufti MR, Németh K, Murcia H, Lindsay JM, El-Masry N (2013) Geosite of a steep lava spatter cone of the 1256 AD, Al Madinah eruption, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Cent Eur J Geosci 5:189–195
Moufti MR, Németh K, El-Masry N, Qaddah A (2015) Volcanic geotopes and their geosites preserved in an arid climate related to landscape and climate changes since the neogene in Northern Saudi Arabia: Harrat Hutaymah (Hai’il Region). Geoheritage 7:103–118
Mrlina J, Kämpf H, Kroner C, Mingram J, Stebich M, Brauer A, Geissler WH, Kallmeyer J, Matthes H, Seidl M (2009) Discovery of the first Quaternary maar in the Bohemian Massif, Central Europe, based on combined geophysical and geological surveys. J Volcanol Geotherm Res 182:97–112
Németh K, Martin U (2007) Shallow sill and dyke complex in western Hungary as a possible feeding system of phreatomagmatic volcanoes in “soft-rock” environment. J Volcanol Geotherm Res 159:138–152
Palliardi AA (1863) Der Kammerbühl ein Vulkan bei Kaiser Franzensbad. 115 pp.
Panizza M (2001) Geomorphosites: Concepts, methods and examples of geomorphological survey. Chin Sci Bull 46:4–6
Panizza M (2009) The geomorphodiversity of the dolomites (Italy): a key of geoheritage assessment. Geoheritage 1:33–42
Petronis MS, Delcamp A, van Wyk de Vries B (2013) Magma emplacement into the Lemptégy scoria cone (Chaîne Des Puys, France) explored with structural, anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility, and Paleomagnetic data. Bull Volcanol 75:753
Petronis MS, Brister AR, Rapprich V, van Wyk de Vries B, Lindline J, Mišurec J (2015) Emplacement history of the Trosky basanitic volcano (Czech Republic): paleomagnetic, rock magnetic, petrologic, and anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility evidence for lingering growth of a monogenetic volcano. J Geosci 60:129–147
Proft E (1894) Kammerbühl und Eisenbühl, die Schicht-Vulkane des Egerer beckens. Jahrb Geol Reichsanstalt 1:25–86
Rajchl M, Uličný D, Grygar R, Mach K (2009) Evolution of basin architecture in an incipient continental rift: the Cenozoic Most Basin, Eger Graben (Central Europe). Basin Res 21:269–294
Rapprich V, Shields S, Halodová P, Lindline J, van Wyk de Vries B, Petronis MS, Valenta J (2017a) Fingerprints of magma mingling processes within the Miocene Zebín tuff cone feeding system (Jičín Volcanic Field, Czech Republic). J Geosci 62:215–229
Rapprich V, Lisec M, Fiferna P, Závada P (2017b) Application of modern technologies in popularisation of the Czech Volcanic Geoheritage. Geoheritage 9:413–420
Reck H (1927) Zur Geologie der jüngsten Vulkane Böhmens des Kammerbühls und Eisenbühls bei Eger. – Zeitschrift für Vulkanologie Berlin
Reuss FA (1790) Orographie der Nordwestlichen Mittelgebirges in Bohmen. Ein Beitrag zur Beantwortung der Frage: Ist der Basalt vulkanisch oder nicht?. – Walther, Dresden, 180 pp.
Reuss FA (1793) Mineralogische Geographie von Böhmen. – Prag, 195 pp.
Reuss FA (1794) Sammlung naturhistorischer Aufsätze mit vorzuglicher Hinsicht auf die Mineral-Geschichte Böhmens. 398 pp., Prag, Caspar Widtmann, 1796- I. Uiber einen Basalt von pyramidenförmig abgesonderten Stücken aus Böhmen. 1–46
Reuss AE (1850) Bericht über geologishe Untersuchungen in der Umgebung von Franzensbad und Eger. Jahrb. Der K.K. Geol. Reichsanstalt 1:34–49
Reuss AE (1852) Die geognostischen Verhaeltnisse des Egerer Bezirkes und des Ascher Gebietes in Böhmen. – Abhandlungen der k. k. geologischen Reichsanstalt, Bd. 1, Abth. 1, 1–72, Wien
Reynard E, Coratz P, Regolini-Bissing G (2009) Geomorphosites. Verlag Dr. Friedrich Pfeil, München, Germany
Reynard E, Coratza P, Giusti C (2011) Geomorphosites and geotourism. Geoheritage 3:129–130
Risso C, Németh K, Martin U (2006) Proposed geosites on Pliocene to Recent pyroclastic cone fields in Mendoza, Argentina [Geotopvorschläge für pliozäne bis rezente Vulkanfelder in Mendoza, Argentinien]. Z Dtsch Ges Geowiss 157:477–490
Rojík P (2004) New stratigraphic subdivision of the Tertiary in the Sokolov Basin in Northwestern Bohemia. J Czech Geol Soc (J Geosci) 49:173–185
Rossmässler EA (1840) Die Versteinerungen des Braunkohlesandsteines aus der Gegend von Altsattel in Böhmen (Elbogener Kreis). – 42 pp. Dresden-Leipzig.
Rücker C, Günther T, Spitzer K (2006) Three-dimensional modelling and inversion of dc resistivity data incorporating topography – I. Modelling. Geophys J Int 166:495–505
Scrope GP (1825) Considerations on Volcanos: the probable causes of their phenomena, the laws which determine their march, the disposition of their products, and their connexion with the present state and past history of the globe; leading to the establishment of a new theory of the earth. – W. Phillips, London.
Šebor J (1913) Bilinite – a new Czech mineral. Sborník Klubu Přírodovědeckého 1912:1–2
Seifert W, Kämpf H (1994) Ba-enrichment in phlogopite of a nephelinite from Bohemia. Eur J Mineral 6:497–502
Shaw CSJ (2004) The temporal evolution of three magmatic systems in the West Eifel volcanic field, Germany. J Volcanol Geother Res 131:213–240
Šibrava V, Havlíček P (1980) Radiometric age of Plio-Pleistocene volcanic rocks in the Bohemian massif. Věst Ústř Úst Geol 55:129–150
Šimon L, Maglay J (2005) Dating of sediments underlying the Putikov vŕšok volcano lava flow by the OSL method. Mineralia Slovaca 37:279–281
Skácelová Z, Rapprich V, Valenta J, Hartvich F, Šrámek J, Radoň M, Gaždová R, Nováková L, Kolínský P, Pécskay Z (2010) Geophysical research on structure of partly eroded maar volcanoes: Miocene Hnojnice and Oligocene Rychnov volcanoes (northern Czech Republic). J Geosci 55:333–345. https://doi.org/10.3190/jgeosci.072
Slaby D, Ladwig R (1999) Abraham Gottlob Werner - seine Zeit und seine Bezüge zur Bergwirtschaft. Verlag der TU Bergakademie, Freiberg ISSN 0949-9970
Špičák A, Horálek J (2001) Possible role of fluids in the process of earthquake swarm generation in the West Bohemia/Vogtland seismoactive region. Tectonophysics 336(1):151–161
Špičáková L, Uličný D, Koudelková G (2000) Tectonosedimentary evolution of the Cheb Basin (NW Bohemia, Czech Republic) between late Oligocene and Pliocene: a preliminary note. Stud Geophys Geod 44:556–580
Stenonis N (1669) De solido intra solidum naturaliter contento dissertationis prodromus. Florentiae: ex typographia sub signo stellae, 1669. ETH-Bibliothek Zürich, Rar 1223, https://doi.org/10.3931/e-rara-8552/Public DomainMark, 78 S., [1] Bl. : Ill. (1 Tafel); 25 cm
Šternberk KM (1820–1838) Versuch einer geognostisch-botanischen Darstellung der Flora der Vorwelt. (Vol. 1–8)
Tietz O, Büchner J, Lapp M (2017) The Stolpen Volcano in the Lausitz Volcanic Field (East Germany) – Volcanological, Petrographic and Geochemical Investigations at the Type Locality of Basalt. In: Magna T, Rapprich V (eds): Basalt 2017 Kadaň: Abstracts and excursion guides. – Czech Geological Society and Czech Geological Survey, 57–58
Ulrych J, Ackerman L, Balogh K, Hegner E, Jelínek E, Pécskay Z, Přichystal A, Upton BGJ, Zimák J, Foltýnová R (2013) Plio-Pleistocene basanitic and melilititic series of the Bohemian Massif: K-Ar ages, major/trace element and Sr–Nd isotopic data. Chem Erde-Geochem 73:429–450
Valenta J, Rapprich V, Skácelová Z, Gaždová R, Fojtíková L (2014a) The newly discovered Neogene maar volcano near the Mariánské Lázně, Western Bohemia. Acta Geodyn Geomater 11:107–116
Valenta J, Rapprich V, Stárková M, Skácelová Z, Fojtíková L, Staňek F, Bálek J (2014b) Problems and challenges in detection of pre-Mesozoic maar volcanoes: example from the Principálek Volcano in the Permian Krkonoše Piedmont Basin. J Geosci 59:169–181
Váně M (1961) Earth fires in the Tertiary of northwestern Bohemia. Acta Univ Carolinae, Andean Geol 2:219–234 (in Czech)
Von Born IE (1773) Über einen ausgebrannten Vulcan bei der Stadt Eger in Böhmen. Praha. 16 pp.
Von Cotta B (1832) Die Dendrolithen in Beziehung auf ihren inneren Bau. – Arnoldische Buchhandlung, Dresden, Leipzig, 87 pp.
Von Cotta B (1866) Rocks classified and described: a treatise on lithology. Longmans, Green and Co, London, p 395
Wagner GA, Gögen K, Jonckhere R, Wagner I, Woda C (2002) Dating of Quaternary volcanoes Komorní Hůrka (Kammerbühl) and Železná Hůrka (Eisenbühl), Czech Republic, by TL, ESR, alpha-recoil and fission track chronometry. Z Geol Wiss 30:191–200
Walker GPL (1973) Explosive volcanic eruptions—a new classification scheme. Geol Rundsch 62:431–446
Werner AG (1787) Kurze Klassifikation und Beschreibung der verschiedenen Gebirgsarten. - Walther, 28 pp.
Žáček V, Skála R, Chlupáčová M, Dvořák Z (2005) Ca-Fe3+-rich, Si-undersaturated buchite from Želénky, North-Bohemian brown coal basin Czech Republic. Eur J Mineral 17:623–633
Žáček V, Skála R, Dvořák Z (2010) Rocks and minerals formed by fossil combustion pyrometamorphism in the Neogene brown coal Most Basin Czech Republic. Bull Mineralogicko-Petrologického Oddělení Národního Muzea 18:1–32
Žáček V, Skála R, Dvořák Z (2015) Combustion metamorphism in the Most Basin, Czech Republic. In: Stracher GB, Praksh A, Sokol EV (eds) coal and peat fires: a global perspective. Volume 3: Case studies–coal fires, Elsevier, pp. 161–199
Zippe FXM (1829) Verhandlungen der Gesselschaft des vaterländisches Museums 1, 30, 310. Prag.
Zolitschka B, Negendank JFW, Lottermoser BG (1995) Sedimentological proof and dating of the early Holocene volcanic eruption of Ulmener maar (Vulkaneifel, Germany). Geol Rundsch 84:213–219
Acknowledgements
The project of Re-opening of the historical adits in Komorní hůrka Volcano is supported by the programme of Regional Cooperation between the Regions and the Institutes of the Czech Academy of Sciences in (grant R100121621). This contribution has been prepared with additional support from the Czech Geological Survey (to Rapprich and Kadlecová) and by New Mexico Highlands University Faculty Research funds (to Petronis). The quality of the manuscript benefited from constructive comments by an anonymous reviewer and Károly Németh, as well as from recommendations by handling editor Kevin Page. Special thanks are addressed to Francis van Wyk de Vries for careful language editing.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rapprich, V., Valenta, J., Brož, M. et al. A Crucial Site in the Argument Between Neptunists and Plutonists: Reopening of the Historical Adit in the Komorní hůrka (Kammerbühl) Volcano After 180 Years. Geoheritage 11, 347–358 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12371-018-0286-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12371-018-0286-z