Debates Around Jixia: Argument and Intertextuality in Warring States Writings Associated with the State of Qi

0455251 - OÚ 2016 RIV US eng J - Journal Article
Weingarten, Oliver
Debates Around Jixia: Argument and Intertextuality in Warring States Writings Associated with the State of Qi.
Journal of the American Oriental Society. Roč. 135, č. 2 (2015), s. 283-308. ISSN 0003-0279
Institutional support: RVO:68378009
Keywords : Jixia * Warring States * political debates * intertextual relationship
OECD category: History (history of science and technology to be 6.3, history of specific sciences to be under the respective headings)

The character of the scholarly patronage community of Jixia in the Warring States (480–221 b.c.e.) polity of Qi has been hotly debated. Was it indeed an “academy,” as it has been retrospectively dubbed? What kind of activities did resident scholars engage in? What teachings did they propound, what writings did they compose? Following the lead of research by Nathan Sivin and Andrew S. Meyer, the present article does not treat Jixia as an academy proper, but assumes that it was a patronage community sponsored by the Tian/Chen clan. Rather than indulge in more speculations about institutional arrangements and the activities of specific scholars, however, it is argued that intertextual relationships are more likely to shed light on the intellectual concerns of scholars at Jixia. To demonstrate the viability of such an approach, this article analyzes dialogues between King Xuan of Qi (319–301 b.c.e.) and Master Meng in the book Mengzi, demonstrating that they can be divided into hostile and supportive ones, the latter propounding the principle of “sharing pleasures.” Dialogues included in other compilations that advocate the same principle are then shown to be almost invariably associated with Jixia scholars. The notion of sharing pleasures, it is finally argued, was part of a wider political debate on princely wastefulness that was characteristic of Qi and is likewise reflected in such compilations as Guanzi, Yanzi chunqiu, and Liu tao.
Permanent Link: http://hdl.handle.net/11104/0255913