Hume's Scepticism Revisited

0429672 - FLÚ 2015 RIV GB eng J - Journal Article
Parusniková, Zuzana
Hume's Scepticism Revisited.
Philosophy. Roč. 89, č. 4 (2014), s. 581-602. ISSN 0031-8191
Institutional support: RVO:67985955
Keywords : David Hume * scepticism * Pyrrhonism * early modern epistemology * practical philosophy
Subject RIV: AA - Philosophy ; Religion

I shall situate Hume's scepticism within a broader philosophical and historical context. Firstly, I shall consider the place of Hume's thought within the early modern break with the almost millennium long metaphysical tradition, a break initiated by Descartes. The framework of being structured by a universal order was replaced by the individual human mind that broke free from any higher authority and became an autonomous cognitive agent. Subsequently, the ontological self-evidence of the world or the possibility of adequate knowledge came under sceptical attack. Hume firmly belongs to this discourse and can be seen as the most consistent exponent of this early modern sceptical line. In this light, the 'New Hume' claim that Hume was an ontological realist will be shown to be misplaced in principle. Secondly, the strong influence of Pyrrhonism on Hume's philosophy will be considered, together with his concept of mitigated scepticism. The Pyrrhonian legacy is especially noticeable in Hume's acceptance of the weakness of reason and in his emphasis on the instructive role of philosophy - instead of attempting to make it the foundation of science it becomes a guide to a balanced, happy life. In this respect, Hume stands outside the early modern mainstream in philosophy.
Permanent Link: http://hdl.handle.net/11104/0234744